Old World Sparkle: Why Old Cut Diamonds Still Dazzle Today

In an age of modern brilliance and laser precision, there’s something quietly captivating about a diamond that wears its history in its facets.

Old cut diamonds - particularly the old mine cut and old European cut - are making a romantic resurgence among jewellery lovers seeking authenticity, charm, and a whisper of old-world glamour.

At Simon West Fine Jewellery, we’ve long been drawn to the unique beauty of vintage diamonds, and it’s no surprise that more clients are embracing them in their search for antique engagement rings and timeless bespoke pieces.

What Are Old Cut Diamonds?

Old cut diamonds refer to stones that were cut by hand during the 18th and 19th centuries, before the advent of modern diamond-cutting technology.

These cuts were designed to sparkle under candlelight, resulting in a soft, moody glow rather than the fiery brilliance we associate with today’s laser-cut stones.

Two of the most beloved antique cuts are:

• Old Mine Cut: Squarish with slightly rounded corners, a high crown, deep pavilion, and a small table. These cuts often have an open culet and thick girdle.

• Old European Cut: Round in shape, the predecessor to the modern round brilliant. It features a small table, large facets, and a higher crown, giving it a distinctive domed appearance and a romantic, mellow sparkle.

Unlike their modern counterparts, these diamonds weren’t cut for symmetry or maximum light return under fluorescent lights.

Instead, they were shaped by artisans who responded to the raw diamond’s natural form, often resulting in a one-of-a-kind silhouette and personality.

Why Vintage Diamonds Are Captivating a New Generation

In recent years, there’s been a notable shift in taste.

Today’s jewellery clients - especially engagement ring buyers - are moving away from cookie-cutter perfection and gravitating toward pieces that feel personal, storied, and unique.

Old cut diamonds embody these values beautifully.

Here’s why they continue to enchant:

1. Romantic History

Every old cut diamond carries a sense of legacy. Whether it’s a genuine antique stone or a newly cut diamond in a vintage style, the aesthetic calls to mind an era of romance, poetry, and elegance.

These diamonds were often featured in Georgian, Victorian, and Edwardian jewellery - eras steeped in symbolism and craftsmanship.

2. A Softer Sparkle

Unlike the sharp, rainbow flashes of modern diamonds, old cut diamonds exude a warm, candlelit shimmer. This gentle sparkle feels intimate and nostalgic - perfect for those who favour subtlety and emotion over spectacle.

3. Sustainable and Ethical Choice

Repurposing or resetting vintage diamonds means less environmental impact, as no new mining is required. For eco-conscious buyers, choosing an old cut stone is a beautiful way to blend sustainability with sentimentality.

Designing with Old Cut Diamonds

At Simon West Fine Jewellery, we’ve had the pleasure of designing countless antique-inspired engagement rings and romantic jewellery pieces featuring old cut stones.

Whether you’re sourcing a genuine antique or opting for a newly cut diamond in the old European style, our bespoke process helps bring your vision to life.

Here are some ideas to consider:

• Antique Engagement Rings: Combine an old mine cut diamond with delicate hand-engraved shoulders or millegrain detailing for a piece that feels straight out of a vintage fairytale.

• Solitaire Settings: Let the stone do the talking. An old European cut in a simple yellow gold or platinum claw setting allows the character of the diamond to shine through.

• Halo Designs: Surround your vintage diamond with modern round brilliants for a blend of old and new - perfect for clients who want heirloom appeal with a touch of sparkle.

• Custom Heirloom Reset: Have an old cut diamond handed down from a relative? We can create a custom setting that reflects your style while honouring its history.

A Quiet Luxury That Stands the Test of Time

There’s a refined elegance in choosing jewellery that isn’t loud or trendy.

As the world rediscovers the value of understated luxury, old cut diamonds have found new life in the hearts of people who appreciate character, craftsmanship, and timeless beauty.

Whether you’re inspired by antique design or looking to create something uniquely yours, we’re here to guide you on the journey.

At Simon West Fine Jewellery, we believe that a diamond should speak to your heart, not just your eyes.